The John Batchelor Show

Brief

Irony Burning

| 2 Comments
 


Superb-looking drama of Guadalcanal, Iwo Jima, Okinawa and the Peleliu invasions by the responsible Hollywood duo of Spielberg and Hanks. The Pacific War against the Japanese is rich with doubts.  A burning Bunker Hill off Okinawa is the least of the irony.  The imperial aggression was fed in 1905 by the TR-imposed peace treaty that enslaved Korea to Tokyo and at the same time alienated Tokyo from both Washington and Petersburg. At war with the Triple Entente, Berlin invited Tokyo to its side during the First War, and the failed effort produced the strange alliance of Berlin and Tokyo predators in 1941. Why did we smash Japan? Because it attacked Pearl Harbor. Why did Japan attack Pearl Harbor? Because we cut off its commodities, especially oil, and threatened more? Why? Puzzle continues. The Pacific was a massively brutal and merciless war between two peoples who do not have anything in common and barely want what the other guy has. Sad, blunt ironies.  Iwo Jima and Okinawa proved little and destroyed many, and to what end?  The bombs that we used against helpless civilians produced industrial mass murder with incendiaries in Tokyo.

Bunker Hill.jpg

2 Comments

No-one blames FDR for goading the Japanese empire over oil supplies. Historians never critique FDR for his appeasement at Yalta. Bush 43 is blamed for all the evil in the world today.

Once there is (or has been) a war, all questions must cease. War has never been rational. In war only winning counts. War results when reason has failed; when compromise has been swept aside. No one wants war, but war is hard-wired into the human condition because reason must invariably mutate in to paradox.

We won WWII. The losses we suffered must now be sanctified. It does no good to question how we won or why we were there in the first place; unless it is to foment fresh discord. I do not trust Hollywood's handling of history. There have been too many egregious examples that have caused me to question Hollywood's agenda. This is the reason I am no longer connected to cable.

http://peterkoelliker.blogspot.com/

Leave a comment