Gangland.
The VBIED operation that struck the government block in central Baghdad is a reprise of the attack from the summer that was blamed, back then, on dissidents, Al Qaeda, Saddamists, miscreants and the Sunni riff-raff of Anbar, too. The Reuters team might as well have included Al Capone, Cochise, the Medici, and perhaps also Pontius Pilate's short goons for all the specificity in the blame-shifting. Awaiting best intelligence source, my guess is that the Arab wiseguys struck at the Ministry of Justice building on purpose and with careful prep. If you can strike into Central Baghdad, you can get past what you want and hit where you aim. My intelligence from the summer strike was that it was a gangland feud, the Sunni gangs striking the Shia gangs (who run the central government) and that this is typical of conflict resolution in Iraq. In sum, the summer attack was nothing to do with Al Qaeda; it was about money. My guess is that this strike today is also about money. New York can understand strikes about money. We empty buildings before we blow them up (Citibank, BAC); in Baghdad, they just detonate. The added twist is that as the US withdrawal troops and support of Maliki government (right at the ruins of the Ministry of Justice), these attacks will become more effective in Baghdad. The reprisals by the Maliki government -- throat-cutting, major sweeps, torture like flu season, numerous disappearances -- will not be on video. Business as usual in the uncivil society of the Ummah. Democracy?
Saudi Arabia Democracy.
My conversation last week with Robert Lacey, author, "Inside the Kingdom," reminded me that the notion of democracy that is practiced here and in Western Europe and parts of Asia (where British or American power is present) is not welcome nor credible in the Ummah. The clan and family and polygamous, half-brother-stew, no-women's-rights culture of the Ummah undercuts the assumptions we make about the voting rights of a national. Even the word citizen is futile. A woman in Arabia has no discernible rights, as we understand them. Children are ignored as irrelevant, unless they are puppets who may grow up someday to become just like Dad, a potentate wannabee sneak. The idea of open voting is not entertained. The House of al-Saud, which is entirely derived from the many male children begat by the savage, illiterate, cowardly and absurd desert warlord and witch Ibn Saud (below, with six of his sons), is an uncivil society of strangers who claim friendship, enemies who ignore reason, arbitrary decisions, meaningless feuds, whining potentates, and the vaguely comic figure of old, old, old King Abdullah, 86, who survived this long because he is the only one who has a high opinion of his credibility. Sad, miserable, lurid, stupid half-brothers make up the House of Saud. We would pay them all off as Citibank VPs and send them to the retraining schools. The al-Sauds are unemployable. But in this science fiction scenario that is the current Ummah, the al-Sauds are the posse that gets to decide what is democracy and what is not. None of this is fixed by tradition. All of it started with the paranoia after the attack on the Grand Mosque at Mecca by lunatic Arab punks who had fallen in to cult practices with suicidal, Oedipal gestures because of their rotten educations and teenaged isolation in the Arab backwardness of Riyadh. The old, ignorant, superstitious, facile and now dead King Fahd and the current and dying Abdullah have prosecuted a Wahhabist cruelty and stupidity that did not exists before 1980 and will not again when the Ibn Saud brood gets off the planet. For now, what happens in the Ummah, and especially what happens in Iraq and the Middle East, depends upon the imaginations of the al-Sauds. Limited, cynical, blinded, lustful, hollow characters, uncivil society -- no succession planning worth solving, no confidence, doomed. America has no ally in the House of Al-Saud. The whimsical and clumsy Bush administration wasted reason, time, its best practices on maneuvering around and with the al-Saud gang. In the end it came to falsehoods, greed and superstition. The Obama administration is equally ill-equipped to make sense of a cabal of fools, liars, theives and cut-throats who buy off what they can't buy killed-off. The long dance about Afghanistan and Iraq is part of the Abdullah paranoia that Tehran will sweep Riyadh into the desert from where it came and use the Shia of Eastern Arabia as a colony of vipers in the oilfields. Bush did not have an answer. POTUS does not have an answer. Until and if there is an American executive that treats the al-Sauds as gangsters and bullies, there will be turmoil and larceny in the Gulf. The Wahhabist fantasy that is practiced today has no more theological credibility than a cartoon. In this age of web cynicism, POTUS treats Abdullah and his wicked kin as sovereigns. If France was a kingship, if Germany was an empire, what worth would it be to regard royalty as sovereign and empire as divine? Folly.


The great achievement of the Surge was that Iraq is now a failed state on the order of Lebanon in the 1970s, not Somalia in the 1990s. I don't say that to be sarcastic: it was an historic achievement.
You can't stay in Iraq. if you leave large bases there, they will be attacked at the first sign of weakness, as the Brits were attacked at the start of WWII, which required an allocation of troops the Brits could not afford.
However, Vietnam also teaches us you can't abandon the place. We will have a huge State, USAID, CT and Mil-to-Mil presence there for years (decades?) to come.
This is a painful, low-intensity financial and human strain that we are stuck with: you break it, you pay for it.
However, that does not mean that the Middle East won't have "Democracy," or at least Representative government. It already has a representative tradition through Majalis. What that becomes over times remains unclear.
I'd say the al Saud's have been clobbered by adjectives. Over-active thesaurus today?
Anyway, it's a very cool picture. Someone needs to Photshop faces of BO, Rahm, David, Anita, Jerimiah, Vance, Eric.
"I'd say the al Saud's have been clobbered by adjectives. Over-active thesaurus today?"
I am a great admirer of Mr. Batchelor's extraordinary literary works, and regard it as sinful that they never received their proper due. But in his writings for this website he employs modifiers the way the US military uses theromobaric weapons, to create a vacuum in the target area. Oh, the humanity!
I just love it when I sit down to comment, and someone has already said it better than I ever could. Tonight, JimJinNJ wins the prize.
Great piece, JB!
Saudi princes foment rebellion around the Muslim world, blow-back is inevitable. Chickens do come home to roost.
The Kingdom has done little to spread goodwill globally. Their Swiss and Cayman accounts tell me they can leave on a moment's notice, and will.
Billions in oil revenue can buy a lot of protection, phone taps, and spies, but can it delay the inevitable?
Painting looks like it came from a spaghetti western, the magnificent seven. It has a Maoist-Stalinist flavor to it.
>This is a painful, low-intensity financial and human strain that we are stuck with
Only for as long as the Chinese lend us the money to keep Iraq under occupation.
. . . which is, after all, in their interest.
I still remember seeing Japanese Flags on the cargo ships bringing US Troops and Equipment into the KSA in 1990 and '91. For a time in the late 1980s and early 1990s, our chief contribution to the Global Economy was mercenary service. Looks like we might be back to that.
>which is, after all, in their interest
As for our country, she has gone from the gold standard to the F-16 standard. Our Founding Fathers must be very proud indeed.